@hollie4333
Profile
Registered: 2 weeks, 6 days ago
Relay-Based PWM: Feasibility and Alternatives
Relays are ill-suited for PWM applications and is impractical for everyday electronic systems. Relays are electromechanical switches designed to turn circuits on and off by mechanically actuating terminals, and they are not engineered for rapid switching. Their mechanical construction imposes critical performance barriers that render them unsuitable for PWM. Most commercial relays can cycle no more than 5–10 times per second, while PWM often demands switching frequencies of hundreds or even thousands times per second to precisely control power to devices like motors or lights.
(image: https://info.orcid.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/affilsblog.png)
If you attempt PWM via relay switching will quickly uncover multiple serious drawbacks. First, انواع رله switching arms fail prematurely under frequent switching, causing unexpected malfunction. Second, the switching speed is far too slow to maintain consistent energy modulation. What you get instead is a series of loud clicks and jittery energy fluctuations that can cause mechanical resonance, acoustic interference, or unstable illumination in LEDs. Finally, voltage transient generated when inductive loads the relay opens can pitting the terminals and compromise the connected microcontroller or driver chip.
For true, reliable PWM control, you should utilize semiconductor switching devices such as semiconductor-based relays. Solid-state switches can operate at frequencies exceeding 20 kHz over billions of cycles and at extremely high efficiency. They can be driven by PWM signal generators to enable fine-tuned regulation over the energy output to a target device. An N-channel MOSFET paired with a proper gate driver and a thermal management system can support loads over 10A and ensure consistent modulation consistently.
In cases where your setup that demands pulse width modulation and you only have relays available, you should revise your approach. Limit the relay to coarse on, and apply solid-state switching for a semiconductor switch. Consider this scenario: you might use a relay to turn a large heater on for a full cycle and a transistor to dim an LED array within that cycle.
In summary, using relays for PWM is unfeasible for PWM control. The reliance on moving parts makes them inadequately responsive, audibly disruptive, and prone to failure for the high-frequency switching that modern control systems need. Always choose semiconductor switches like IGBTs and MOSFETs when you need PWM. Semiconductor switches respond quicker, operate silently, exhibit higher energy efficiency, and significantly more robust for this type of application.
Website: https://md.chaosdorf.de/QovpY2w4TwqVdVD47S6EYQ/
Forums
Topics Started: 0
Replies Created: 0
Forum Role: Participant